!!
 

    -    -    -        -

   :    
   ":  
   :  
   :



kaluach

:
   
   
   
   
   
   

 
Word .

  (...)

***********************************

 *********

 

 

" , ( " " 83)

 

 

 

  "" , , .   : .

 

  , , :

 

.   (", ) :

 

" , ' , ', .   '".

 

  , ( ), ', , , , : " () , .   ', , .

 

.   (", ) , :

 

" , ... , , ..., ... ... , ' , ... , ( ), , , , ".

 

  , , ', ' , , .

 

.   (", "") :

 

" , , ' , , , , , , ' .   ... ... , '... ... ' , .   , .   , , ... ... ".

 

  , ,     , ' (), , ' .   , ( , , ), , , '.   .   , , , .   , , .

 

  " , , ( , ), , , , .   : , , , .   , .

 

  , : , " , : " ".   ( , : " " ) : '.

 

  :

 

.   (", ) :

 

"... ', , , ', ... .   : ?   , ' , , , ' , , , ' ".

 

  ', " , .   .

 

.   (", , ) :

 

" , ', , ... ... , , , .   , ... , ".

 

  ', .   , ': .

 

.   (", , ) :

 

" , , ' .   , ' , , ', ".

 

  (", ) :

 

" ' , , ' ".

 

  ' , ' () , ' .   ( ) " --.

 

  , .   .

 

  " , .

 

  .

 

  , , .

 

  :

 

.   (", ), , :

 

" : ... , ".

 

  ' .   , ?   " "?   , , , .   ": - .

 

  , ', .   , , , , .   ' , , - .   ', .

 

  : .   , : .   , .

 

.   : - , , .   .   , ( ), , , .

 

  .

 

  :

 

.   , ' , .   ', .   ' , .

 

  .

 

.   : (', ) :

 

" ' , ...         ,       .   ' , .   ' , ...     , ,       , , .   ' ... , .   ' , ".

 

  , ' .   , , .   ' .   .

 

  .   , ' .   .   " " ' , , .   " ... " " ' " : " ' ".

 

  .   "     " - , .

 

  , .   " ' , " - , , .

 

  " ", : " " , , , , '.   : , ' , .   , , ' .   " ' , , ' ".

 

  , , , .   ":

 

  : , '.   , , , '.   ' :

 

.   " (" ' ' ") : " , ' ( "), .   '".   ', ' .   .

 

.   " " ' " " : " ... ... ' , ( )".   , ( "): " ".   " , .

 

  ( : ) , , , : " ", " ".   " .   , , , .

 

  , .   '.   " , , , , .   , :

 

.   " (" ' ") : " , : ' ' : ' ' ' ( "), , ".   : " , ' .   .       ( ), , , , " ", ',     .   "" ' .

 

.   " (" ' ") : " , : ' ' ' ' ( "), , ".   : , !   " : " " - "           , .

 

.   " , , " .   , '.   .   , , , .   ( : ( " ) .)   , "" ".

 

  " , .

 

 

 

  ushin then in this case where there is no ma'aseh geirushin at all it is reasonable that no prohibition to a kohen is created.   However, if the ma'aseh geirushin is complete, but there is a side problem which prevents the get from taking effect, then it is certainly possible that a prohibition to a kohen is effected )see shiur #20(.   If the eidim function as potential testimony, then it is reasonable that the eidim are a condition necessary for the kiddushin to take effect.   However, they are merely an external requirement.   Therefore, the absence of the eidim will have no negative effect on the ma'aseh per se.   If, on the other hand, the very presence of the eidim transforms the kiddushin into an official public ceremony, then the eidim are functioning as an integral part of the ma'aseh kiddushin.  Consequently, lack of eidim invalidates the ma'aseh kiddushin itself.   )See Kometz Mincha mitzva 206(.Summary: We have developed two basic approaches regarding eidut le-kiyum ha-davar:1. Gittin and kiddushin require verifiability in order to take effect.2. In gittin and kiddushin, the actual presence of eidim is necessary;a. in order to insure intent.b. as part of the official ceremonial nature of gittin and kiddushin.   According to the first approach, any potential documentation may be accepted, while the second approach requires the actual presence of eidim during the ceremony.   The first approach would view the witnesses as an external condition necessary for gittin and kiddushin, while the second approach would likely consider the eidim as an intrinsic element of the ma'aseh.For further research:1. How can the second approach possibly derive eidut le-kiyum ha-davar from monetary litigation?2. See the Rambam and Ra'avad Hilkhot Ishut 7:23; 3:15; Rambam Hilkhot Geirushin 6:1-4.   What is the argument between the Rambam and the Ra'avad based on?   Is this related in some way to the variant approaches developed in this shiur?**************************************************************For more shiurim, see our website: http://www.vbm-torah.org**************************************************************Copyright )c( 1996 Yeshivat Har Etzion.   All rights reserved.**************************************************************   YESHIVAT HAR ETZION   VIRTUAL BEIT MIDRASH    ALON SHEVUT, GUSH ETZION 90433   E-MAIL: YHE@virtual.CO.IL or office@etzion.org.il____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

___________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ײ___‏___E__,F__-F__F__F__‹G__G__G__G__G__G__׳׳_____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________;_CJ__OJ__QJ___:_CJ__OJ__QJ___CJ__OJ_QJ_mH   __
CJ__OJ__QJ____CJ__OJ__QJ__mH   ______‏ 07 2005___<P__{___|_________₪___ײ___׳___‎___‏______ׁ  __ׂ   __   __   __
__
__b___c___________q____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________,__$__„__„___₪__ֶ__‏ 07 2005___‏8:47 "__‏8:47 "$‏8:47 ",__$__„__„___₪__ֶ__‏ 07 2005___  ,__$__„__„___₪________‏ 07 2005___<P__{___|_________₪___ײ___׳___‎___‏______ׁ  __ׂ   __   __   __
__
__b___c___________q___r___†___‡__________3___4___&
__'
__w___x_________%__€%__O)__P)__e)__f)__,__¯,__&4__'4__ֹ:__ֺ:__:__:__O?__P?__“A__”A__A__A__A__A__1B__xB__–B__B__B__MD__ND__dD__eD__ֶD__E__E__E__-F__lF__F__F__F___G__=G__kG__G__₪G__G__G__G__G__‏‏‏‏‏‏‏‏‏‏‏‏‏‏‏‏‏‏‏‏‏‏‏‏‏‏‏‏‏‏‏‏___________________________________________________________________________________________________________‏8:47 ",_‏ 07 2005‏ 07 2005Wq___r___†___‡__________3___4___&
__'
__w___x_________%__€%__O)__P)__e)__f)__,__¯,__&4__'4__ֹ:__ֺ:__:__:__O?__P?_____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________‏8:47 "__‏8:47 "$‏8:47 "_
P?__“A__”A__A__A__A__A__1B__xB__–B__B__B__MD__ND__dD__eD__ֶD__E__E__E__-F__lF__F__F__F___G__=G__kG________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________,_‏8:47 "$‏8:47 "_$__„__„___₪__   ,__$__„__„___₪__‏8:47 "__‏8:47 "$‏8:47 "__kG__G__₪G__G__G__G__G________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________‏8:47 "__‏8:47 "$‏8:47 "  ,__$__„__„___₪___,_‏8:47 "$‏8:47 "_$__„__„___₪____*_   0_0‏ 07 2005&P  _‑P‏ 07 2005__ƒ. ָA!__"__# _$ _%________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________\__‏ 07 2005_]__________‏8:47 "_$__@_$_____N_o_r_m_a_l________mH   _*_‏ 07 2005@A_R_*___   _H_e_a_d_i_n_g_ _1_____‏ 07 2005__₪x___<P@A_R_<P__   _H_e_a_d_i_n_g_ _2______₪ __₪x___6_CJ‑_[_aJ‑_B_‏8:47 "@A_R_B___   _H_e_a_d_i_n_g_ _3____‏8:47 "__₪x__₪P___CJ__OJ__QJ__aJ__kH_H__@A_R_H___   _H_e_a_d_i_n_g_ _4_______₪x__₪P_